🔐 Public vs Private API Keys : Why Public APIs Sometimes Return 404

API keys are a cornerstone of modern web development, giving developers a way to authenticate requests, enforce usage policies, and manage access. But as services grow more complex and security-conscious, understanding the distinction between public and private API keys — and how they behave differently — is more important than ever.

A common frustration many developers face in 2025 is this:

“I’m using a public API key. The request works for my colleague, but for me, it’s returning a 404 Not Found. Why?”

This blog will explore:

  • ✅ What public and private API keys really are

  • ❌ Why exposing private keys in client code is dangerous

  • ⚠️ What causes 404 errors when using public keys

  • 🧪 A real-world example of a key misconfiguration

  • 🛠️ How to test and debug these issues

  • 💻 Best practices with code snippets

  • 📊 Tables for comparison

  • 🔗 Resources to go deeper


🧠 Understanding Public vs Private API Keys

🔓 Public API Key

A public API key is intended for use in frontend or client-side applications. It's considered “public” not because it's safe to share freely — but because it's intended to be embedded in environments you don’t control (like browsers or mobile apps).

  • Typically used for:

    • Embedding Google Maps

    • Calling read-only APIs (e.g. weather, analytics, forms)

    • Static assets or search endpoints

  • Requires usage limits and referrer/IP restrictions

  • Should never grant access to sensitive data or write capabilities

🔐 Private API Key

A private API key should never leave your backend. It is meant to:

  • Authenticate sensitive requests

  • Perform write/delete operations

  • Bypass rate limits

  • Access internal dashboards or resources

  • Be stored in environment variables or secret managers

Exposing private keys in your frontend is the equivalent of giving users access to your internal database credentials.


⚠️ Why Public API Keys May Return 404 For Some Users

It’s easy to assume a 404 means the endpoint doesn’t exist. But when you're dealing with API keys, a 404 Not Found might actually mean:

  • Your request was blocked silently

  • The request came from an unauthorized domain or referrer

  • Your IP was not whitelisted

  • The API is intentionally hiding the resource to prevent information disclosure

Many cloud platforms and services — like Google Cloud, Firebase, or Supabase — return 404 instead of 403/401 when referrer/IP rules are broken. This is a stealth protection mechanism to avoid exposing details about the backend or endpoint structure.


🧪 Case Study: Firebase Returning 404 on Public Key

Problem:
A developer tries to connect to Firebase Firestore using a public API key on their staging server. On production, everything works fine. On staging, every request returns 404.

Investigation:

  • The public key is valid.

  • The endpoint works for others.

  • No other error message — just 404.

Root Cause:
The API key was restricted to production domains only (example.com). The staging domain (staging.example.com) was not added as a referrer.

Firebase silently returned 404 to obfuscate access control policies.

Solution:

  • Added the staging domain to the API key referrer list in Google Cloud Console.

  • Re-ran the request: ✅ it worked.


💻 How to Debug a 404 Caused by a Public API Key

  1. Test with curl or Postman

     curl -H "Origin: http://localhost" \
          "https://api.your-service.com/data?key=PUBLIC_KEY"
    
  2. Inspect HTTP headers in browser

    • Look for:

      • Access-Control-Allow-Origin

      • X-API-Usage or X-Error-Code

      • Unexpected redirects or content types

  3. Check your API key configuration

    • Domain restrictions

    • IP restrictions

    • Expired or disabled keys

  4. Verify endpoint availability

    • Try the same endpoint with another key or from a different machine
  5. Review cloud dashboard logs

    • Google Cloud, AWS, and others provide per-request diagnostics


📊 Comparison Table: Public vs Private API Key Use

FeaturePublic API KeyPrivate API Key
VisibilityBrowser, mobile, exposedBackend, server-only
PermissionsRead-only, scopedFull, admin-level
Referrer/IP restrictions available✅ Yes✅ Yes
Security risk if exposedMedium (abuse potential)High (data leaks, admin actions)
Typical use casesMaps, analytics, searchPayments, user data, write APIs
Can cause 404 if misused✅ Frequently❌ Less likely, usually 401/403

🛡️ Best Practices to Avoid These Issues

Always restrict public keys by referrer, IP, or app ID
Never use private keys in frontend or mobile apps
Use environment variables to inject keys into backends
Rotate API keys every 30-90 days
Monitor key usage and set up alerts
Fail gracefully — handle 404/401/403 and log properly



🧠 Conclusion

Public API keys are not “safe” just because they’re public. When misconfigured, they can either:

  • Leak data and open up abuse vectors, or

  • Fail silently with 404s that confuse and frustrate you.

Always treat API keys as credentials, no matter the type.

If you’re getting 404s from a public API:

  • Check the key’s referrer/IP restrictions

  • Check your Origin headers

  • Don’t assume the endpoint is broken — assume the request is being intentionally blocked


API keys play a crucial role in web development, but understanding the differences between public and private keys is essential as services grow more complex. Public API keys are used in client-side applications and come with restrictions, while private keys should remain in the backend for sensitive operations. Developers may encounter 404 errors with public keys due to referrer or IP restrictions. Best practices include restricting public keys, never exposing private keys in frontends, and closely monitoring usage. Always approach API keys as credentials, and ensure you understand the security implications to avoid misconfigurations.

70
Subscribe to my newsletter

Read articles from Lakshay Dhoundiyal directly inside your inbox. Subscribe to the newsletter, and don't miss out.

Written by

Lakshay Dhoundiyal
Lakshay Dhoundiyal

Being an Electronics graduate and an India Book of Records holder, I bring a unique blend of expertise to the tech realm. My passion lies in full-stack development and ethical hacking, where I continuously strive to innovate and secure digital landscapes. At Hashnode, I aim to share my insights, experiences, and discoveries through tech blogs.