Understanding Monorepos with Nx

AanchalAanchal
12 min read

In the ever-evolving landscape of software development, managing complex codebases efficiently is paramount. As applications grow in size and interconnectedness, traditional multi-repository setups often lead to challenges like code duplication, inconsistent tooling, and cumbersome dependency management. This is where the monorepo shines, and among the tools that empower monorepos, Nx (pronounced "En-Ex", short for Next Generation DevTools) stands out as a powerful and intelligent solution.

What is a Monorepo?

At its core, a monorepo (short for monolithic repository) is a single version control repository that houses the source code for multiple distinct projects. These projects might include:

  • Multiple frontend applications (e.g., a customer-facing web app, an admin dashboard, a mobile app).

  • Various backend services (e.g., a REST API, a microservice for background tasks).

  • Shared libraries and UI component libraries used across different applications.

  • Tooling configurations, documentation, and infrastructure code.

While the term "monolithic" might bring to mind a single, tightly coupled codebase, a monorepo with proper tooling (like Nx) encourages modularity and separation of concerns. It's about centralizing your code, not necessarily bundling it into one giant application.

Why Nx for Your Monorepo?

While basic monorepos can be set up with tools like Yarn Workspaces or npm Workspaces, Nx takes it to the next level, offering a comprehensive suite of features that transform a simple multi-package repository into a "smart repo." Here's why Nx has become a go-to choice for organizations of all sizes:

  1. Optimized Performance with Intelligent Caching:

    • Nx employs a smart build system that analyzes your project's dependency graph. This means it only rebuilds or retests projects that have been "affected" by recent code changes, drastically reducing build and test times, especially in large repositories.

    • It offers both local and remote caching. Local caching stores build artifacts on your machine, while remote caching (via Nx Cloud) allows your entire team to share these artifacts, ensuring consistent and blazing-fast CI/CD pipelines.

  2. Code Sharing and Reusability at Scale:

    • Nx promotes the creation of reusable libraries. You can easily extract common UI components, utility functions, business logic, or data access layers into dedicated libraries that can be consumed by multiple applications within the monorepo. This fosters the "Don't Repeat Yourself" (DRY) principle and ensures consistency across your products.

    • It simplifies dependency management by allowing a single version of third-party dependencies across the entire monorepo, reducing conflicts and ensuring all projects stay up-to-date.

  3. Powerful Code Generation and Scaffolding:

    • Nx provides rich generators that can quickly scaffold new applications, libraries, components, services, and more, pre-configured with industry-standard tooling (e.g., React, Angular, Next.js, NestJS, Vite, Jest, Cypress).

    • This standardization reduces the overhead of setting up new projects, enforces best practices, and minimizes configuration errors.

  4. Visualizing Dependencies with the Project Graph:

    • The nx graph command is a game-changer. It generates an interactive visualization of your monorepo's projects and their interdependencies. This helps developers and architects understand the codebase's structure, identify potential issues, and make informed architectural decisions.
  5. Consistent Development Experience:

    • Nx offers executors that provide a consistent way to run common tasks like serve, build, test, and lint across all projects, regardless of their underlying technology stack.

    • It helps enforce consistent coding standards and tooling configurations (ESLint, Prettier) across the entire workspace.

  6. Simplified Atomic Changes:

    • With a monorepo, you can make changes that span multiple projects (e.g., updating a shared API and the frontend consumer) within a single commit. This simplifies coordination and ensures consistency, eliminating the headache of managing multiple repository commits and releases.

Understanding Features of Nx

1. The Project Graph

At the heart of Nx's intelligence lies the Project Graph. This isn't just a static diagram; it's a dynamic, in-memory representation of your workspace's entire architecture.

  • How it works: Nx scans your nx.json, project.json files, and tsconfig.json files, along with analyzing import statements in your code. It identifies all applications and libraries (libs and apps directories), their implicit and explicit dependencies, and how they relate to each other.

  • Static Analysis: Nx performs static analysis of your code to understand true code dependencies, not just what's declared in package.json. This means it can accurately determine which parts of your codebase are truly affected by a change.

  • Impact: The Project Graph is the foundation for Nx's intelligent caching, affected commands, and visualization tools. It allows Nx to:

    • "Affected" Commands: Determine exactly which projects need to be rebuilt, tested, or linted based on changes to source files or dependencies. When you run nx affected:build, Nx consults the graph to run the build target only for projects that were directly or indirectly impacted.

    • Optimization: Avoid unnecessary computations, saving significant time in local development and CI/CD.

    • Architectural Insights: Provide a clear, up-to-date visual map of your codebase's structure, helping you avoid circular dependencies and enforce architectural boundaries.

2. Computation Caching (Local & Remote)

Nx's caching mechanism is a cornerstone of its performance.

  • Local Caching:

    • When you run a task (e.g., nx build my-app), Nx stores the output of that task (build artifacts, test results, etc.) along with a hash of the inputs (source code, dependencies, configuration) in a local cache directory (.nx/cache).

    • The next time you run the same task with the same inputs, Nx will detect that nothing has changed and instantly retrieve the result from the cache, preventing redundant work. This is incredibly fast, often returning results in milliseconds.

  • Remote Caching (Nx Cloud):

    • For teams, Nx Cloud extends this caching to a shared, remote server. When a developer builds or tests a project, the results are uploaded to Nx Cloud.

    • Subsequent builds or tests by any team member (or CI/CD pipeline) will first check Nx Cloud. If the cached output exists, it's downloaded, again saving significant time and compute resources. This ensures consistency and dramatically speeds up CI.

    • Nx Cloud also offers Distributed Task Execution, allowing you to run tasks in parallel across multiple machines for even faster CI/CD.

3. Executors and Generators

These are the building blocks for standardization and automation in an Nx workspace.

  • Executors:

    • Think of executors as a standardized way to run tasks (like build, serve, test, lint, e2e) for any project within your monorepo.

    • Each project's project.json file defines its targets, and each target points to an executor (e.g., @nx/react:build or @nx/node:serve).

    • Benefits: This creates a consistent command-line interface across diverse technologies. Regardless of whether it's a React app, an Angular app, or a NestJS API, you'll always use nx build <project-name> or nx serve <project-name>, abstracting away the underlying build tools (Webpack, Vite, Rollup, etc.).

  • Generators:

    • Generators are powerful tools for scaffolding new code. Instead of manually creating files, folders, and configurations for a new component, service, or even an entire application, you use a generator (e.g., nx g @nx/react:component my-button --project=shared-ui).

    • Benefits:

      • Standardization: Ensures that all newly generated code adheres to your team's conventions, architecture, and tooling configurations (ESLint, Prettier).

      • Productivity: Drastically speeds up boilerplate creation, allowing developers to focus on business logic.

      • Reduced Errors: Minimizes manual configuration errors and ensures projects are set up correctly from the start.

    • Nx provides a rich set of official plugins (e.g., @nx/react, @nx/angular, @nx/next, @nx/node, @nx/nest, @nx/cypress, @nx/jest) that come with a wide array of pre-built generators and executors. You can also create custom generators tailored to your specific organizational needs.

4. Module Boundary Enforcement

This feature is crucial for maintaining a clean and scalable architecture in a large monorepo.

  • Tags and Constraints: You can assign "tags" to your libraries (e.g., type:ui, scope:product-feature, type:data-access). These tags are defined in the nx property of your project.json file.

  • ESLint Rules: Nx's ESLint plugin (@nx/eslint-plugin) provides rules, notably enforce-module-boundaries, that allow you to define constraints on how projects with certain tags can import from projects with other tags.

    • Example: You can enforce that type:ui libraries can only depend on other type:ui libraries or type:util libraries, but not on type:data-access libraries directly. This prevents your UI from becoming too tightly coupled to data logic.

    • The rule also prevents projects from importing files that are not part of a library's declared public API (usually exposed via its index.ts or index.js).

  • Benefits:

    • Architectural Guardrails: Prevents unintended dependencies and encourages a layered, modular architecture.

    • Improved Maintainability: Makes it easier to refactor and evolve parts of your system without breaking others.

    • Team Scalability: Allows different teams to work on separate parts of the monorepo with confidence that they won't accidentally introduce breaking changes in unrelated domains.

5. Nx Release

Managing releases in a monorepo can be complex, especially when only certain projects have changed. Nx Release simplifies this process.

  • Conventional Commits Integration: Works seamlessly with conventional commits (e.g., feat:, fix:) to automatically determine the next version number for affected projects and generate changelogs.

  • Atomic Releases: Enables you to release multiple packages that have changed in a single, coordinated process, maintaining version consistency across interconnected projects. You can configure projectsRelationship in nx.json to be fixed (all packages release together) or independent (packages release at their own pace based on changes).

  • Publishing: Automates the publishing of new versions of your libraries to npm or other package registries. It integrates with tools like Verdaccio for local testing of published packages.

6. Nx Console (IDE Integration)

For an even smoother developer experience, Nx provides a powerful IDE extension, Nx Console, available for VS Code and WebStorm/IntelliJ.

  • Visual Interface: Offers a graphical user interface for running Nx commands, generating code, and exploring the project graph.

  • IntelliSense and Auto-completion: Provides intelligent suggestions for command options and project names.

  • Error Reporting: Integrates with Nx's error reporting to provide richer feedback directly in your IDE.

  • AI Enhancements: Nx Console can provide workspace context to AI tools (like Copilot), making their suggestions more accurate and relevant to your monorepo's structure and existing code.

  • Nx Cloud Integration: Provides a visual overview of CI pipeline executions from Nx Cloud directly in your editor, with notifications for job completion or errors.

Setting Up Your First Nx Monorepo: A Step-by-Step Guide

Getting started with Nx is straightforward. Let's walk through the process of creating a new Nx workspace:

  1. Install Nx CLI (Optional, but Recommended):

    While npx can be used to run Nx commands without global installation, installing the Nx CLI globally can be convenient for frequent use.

     npm install -g nx
     # or
     yarn global add nx
     # or
     pnpm add -g nx
    
  2. Create a New Nx Workspace:

    Navigate to the directory where you want to create your monorepo and run:

     npx create-nx-workspace@latest my-awesome-monorepo
    

    Nx will prompt you with a series of questions:

    • "Which stack would you like to use?": You can choose from various presets (e.g., react, angular, next, node, nest, empty). Choosing empty gives you a blank slate, while others set up a basic application with the chosen technology.

    • "Application name (e.g., my-app)": If you choose a preset, it will ask for an initial application name.

    • "Enable Nx Cloud? (Y/n)": Highly recommended for collaborative teams to leverage remote caching and distributed task execution.

Once the command completes, you'll have a new directory my-awesome-monorepo with a basic Nx workspace structure.

  1. Explore the Workspace Structure:

    A typical Nx workspace includes:

    • apps/: This directory typically contains your deployable applications (e.g., frontend UIs, backend APIs). Applications should be as lightweight as possible, consuming code from libraries.

    • libs/: This directory is where you'll house your reusable libraries. These libraries should be modular and focused on specific domains (e.g., ui-components, data-access, shared-utils).

    • nx.json: The core Nx configuration file. It defines projects, their types, and how they relate, along with caching strategies and task runners. It also defines global cache inputs/outputs and module boundary rules.

    • package.json: The root package.json for your entire monorepo, listing global dependencies.

    • tsconfig.base.json: The base TypeScript configuration for the entire workspace, defining path aliases for your libraries.

    • project.json (inside each app/lib folder): Defines the specific configurations, targets (build, serve, test, lint), and executors for that individual project. This file is crucial for Nx to understand how to interact with each project.

  2. Generating New Projects (Applications and Libraries):

    Nx provides powerful generators to add new projects.

    • To generate a new React application:

        nx generate @nx/react:application my-frontend --style=css
        # or (shorthand)
        nx g @nx/react:app my-frontend --style=css
      
    • To generate a new Node.js Express API:

        nx generate @nx/node:application my-backend --framework=express
        # or
        nx g @nx/node:app my-backend --framework=express
      
    • To generate a shared TypeScript library:

        nx generate @nx/js:library shared-utils
        # or
        nx g @nx/js:lib shared-utils
      

These commands not only create the necessary files and folders but also update nx.json and tsconfig.json with the new project's configuration and paths.

  1. Running Tasks:

    Nx provides consistent commands for common development tasks:

    • Serve an application:

        nx serve my-frontend
      
    • Build a project:

        nx build my-backend
      
    • Test a project:

        nx test shared-utils
      
    • Lint a project:

        nx lint my-frontend
      
  2. Visualizing the Project Graph:

    To see how your projects and libraries are interconnected, run:

     nx graph
    

    This will open a browser window displaying an interactive dependency graph.

Best Practices for Nx Monorepos

  1. Establish Clear Folder Structure:

    • Organize your apps/ and libs/ directories logically. Common patterns include grouping by domain (e.g., libs/auth, libs/products) or by type (e.g., libs/ui, libs/data-access).

    • Encourage applications to be "thin" clients that primarily orchestrate functionality provided by libraries.

  2. Enforce Module Boundaries (Crucial for Large Teams):

    • Utilize Nx's ESLint plugin (@nx/eslint-plugin) to define strict rules for how libraries can depend on each other using "tags" in nx.json. This is vital for maintaining a healthy, modular architecture and preventing accidental coupling.
  3. Granular Libraries:

    • Break down your shared code into small, focused libraries. Instead of a single shared library, consider shared-ui, shared-utils, shared-types, shared-data-access. This improves reusability, reduces the scope of changes, and optimizes caching.
  4. Utilize Nx Cloud for CI/CD:

    • Nx Cloud's remote caching and distributed task execution can dramatically speed up your CI/CD pipelines. This is crucial for large teams and frequent deployments.
  5. Embrace Generators for Consistency:

    • Beyond the built-in generators, consider creating custom Nx generators for common patterns or boilerplate specific to your organization. This ensures consistency and accelerates development.
  6. Leverage Affected Commands Heavily:

    • Integrate nx affected commands into your CI/CD pipeline. Instead of running nx test-all on every commit, run nx affected:test to only test projects impacted by the changes. This saves significant time and resources and is one of Nx's biggest selling points.
  7. Keep Nx and Plugin Versions in Sync:

    • Regularly update your Nx CLI and plugins to their latest versions to benefit from performance improvements, bug fixes, and new features. Nx's migration system (nx migrate latest) makes this process relatively smooth.
  8. Document Project Ownership:

    • For larger monorepos, clearly define project owners using CODEOWNERS files. This ensures that changes to specific projects require approval from the responsible teams or individuals.
  9. Consider Monorepo vs. Polyrepo Trade-offs:

    • While Nx mitigates many monorepo disadvantages, be aware of potential challenges like larger repository size, potentially longer cloning times (though shallow clones help), and the need for robust access control in highly sensitive environments. Nx is especially suited for scenarios where projects share a significant amount of code, tooling, or deployment pipelines.

Conclusion

Nx has revolutionized how developers approach monorepos, transforming them from potentially unwieldy beasts into highly efficient and scalable development environments. By providing intelligent caching, powerful code generation, dependency visualization, robust module boundary enforcement, and a consistent developer experience, Nx empowers teams to build complex applications faster, more reliably, and with greater collaboration.

If you're looking to streamline your development workflow, improve code sharing, and accelerate your CI/CD pipelines, embracing an Nx monorepo is a strategic decision that can pay significant dividends for your organization.

0
Subscribe to my newsletter

Read articles from Aanchal directly inside your inbox. Subscribe to the newsletter, and don't miss out.

Written by

Aanchal
Aanchal