How to Backtest Sports Betting Strategies the Right Way

Backtesting is a powerful tool for sports bettors who want to validate their strategies using past data before risking real money. But it must be done right — or it can easily give a false sense of confidence.

At Bet Better, backtesting is one of the core components of our methodology. Here’s how we approach it with actuarial discipline, machine learning, and sports intelligence.

---

Why Backtesting Matters

Backtesting helps answer the question:

“Would this strategy have worked historically?”

But it's more than just looking at wins and losses. When done rigorously, backtesting helps:

• Validate assumptions with real data

• Quantify expected returns and variance

• Identify hidden risks or weaknesses

• Prevent overfitting and overconfidence

• Build conviction before scaling a strategy

---

The Right Way to Backtest

At Bet Better, our backtesting process includes:

✅ 1. Clean, Consistent Data

We use standardized historical datasets for teams, players, odds, and market movements — making sure the model isn’t learning from future information (data leakage).

✅ 2. Simulated Betting Outcomes

We replicate what would’ve happened if a user followed a strategy day by day, bet by bet, including odds movement, bet sizing, and any staking rules.

✅ 3. Confidence Intervals & Metrics

We don’t just report a return — we simulate it 1,000+ times (often via Monte Carlo simulations) to get realistic outcome distributions.

Metrics we report include:

• ROI (Return on Investment)

• Strike Rate & Edge %

• Variance / Volatility

• Drawdown periods

• Kelly Criterion performance

✅ 4. Avoiding Overfitting

A model that performs great in backtest but poorly in real life is often "overfit." We use:

• Out-of-sample testing

• Cross-validation

• Walk-forward testing
  To ensure results are repeatable.

---

Use Case: Player Prop Model

Let’s say we create a model for predicting NBA player points. After training the model on 2 years of data, we backtest it on a 3rd unseen season.

We compare:

• Model prediction vs actual result

• Sportsbook line vs outcome

• Bet value (probability vs odds)

If the model shows consistent edge across that 3rd season, that’s meaningful. If not — we improve it before publishing anything live.

---

Our Goal: Trust Through Transparency

You deserve predictions built on solid ground — not guesswork. That’s why we integrate professional-grade backtesting into every Bet Better model.

You can explore our latest Best Bets, or dive deeper into our full Methodology to see how we ensure accuracy, edge, and honesty in everything we publish.