Messing with Docker on MCP Claude Desktop project

My First Big Battle with Docker: A Claude Tool Project Story

Hi there! I'm Alex, a recent math graduate who dove into the world of coding about a year ago. A couple of months ago, I discovered the Claude Desktop app and was immediately inspired to create some custom tools for it using Python.

My journey started by following a YouTube tutorial. Initially, everything was smooth sailing—the project worked perfectly! Encouraged by this early win, I decided to expand it with more realistic and useful custom tools. That's when I had the "brilliant" idea to introduce Docker.

---

The Dream: A Clean, Containerized App

The goal seemed simple enough: I wanted to dockerize my application. However, there was a catch. My collection of Python tools wasn't a standalone application; it was just a set of scripts. To make them accessible from within a Docker container, I needed an interface. So, I decided to build a simple server using FastAPI to expose my tool functions as API endpoints. What could go wrong?

---

The Reality: A Series of Painful Hurdles

As it turns out, a lot could go wrong. The moment I introduced Docker, my smooth-sailing project hit a storm of problems.

1. The Vulnerability Maze 😵‍💫

My first major roadblock was security. The initial Docker base images I chose came with a terrifying list of high-severity vulnerabilities. I spent what felt like an eternity swapping out different images, running security scans, and desperately trying to find a clean, secure foundation for my app. It was a frustrating and eye-opening experience into the world of container security.

2. The Server-Client Standoff 💔

After finally settling on an image and getting my FastAPI server running inside the container, I hit the next wall. I modified the Claude Desktop configuration file to point to my new Dockerized server, but they refused to communicate properly.

I was plagued with cryptic parsing errors and persistent connection failures. It felt like the client (Claude) and my server were in a standoff, and I was stuck in the middle, debugging a communication breakdown I couldn't solve.

---

A Tactical Retreat

After spending countless hours troubleshooting, I found myself at a crossroads. The complexity I had introduced with Docker and FastAPI was completely overshadowing my original goal: to create useful tools.

In the end, I made the tough call to remove Docker and FastAPI from the project. I decided to go back to the beginning, hosting the tools locally and keeping things simple. Instantly, everything worked again.

This journey was a powerful, if humbling, lesson. While technologies like Docker are incredible, they add layers of architectural complexity. I learned that sometimes, the best strategy is to take a step back, simplify your stack, and focus on getting to a working state. My battle with Docker isn't over, but for this project, it was a necessary and tactical retreat.