Should You Go for Granite or Stick with Marble?

If you're planning a kitchen upgrade in Winnipeg, you're probably asking: Should I go with granite or marble? Both are beautiful. Both are natural stones. But they perform very differently in a real, busy kitchen.

At Rockwood Stone Countertops, we have assisted many Winnipeg residents in deciding between granite versus marble countertops in Winnipeg. If you are seeking long-lasting beauty, a smooth surface that supports your lifestyle, and something you are going to be happy to pay for, then this post is the talk you need.

We will draw comparisons between the two stones according to their durability, appearance, price, maintenance and performance- so you can make an informed choice.

What’s the Core Difference Between Granite and Marble?

Granite is harder. Marble is less hard--but finer

• Granite is a volcanic stone that comes from cooled magma. It is tough, stiff and robust.

• Marble is a chemical formation of stone created from limestone. It is softer and with gorgeous veining.

Quick Facts:

• Granite is not as porous as marble is

• Marble is apt to stain and scratch.

• Both are classic and timeless, however have different kitchen applications.

Which One Is More Durable for Daily Use?

Granite takes the win for toughness.

Why granite is more kitchen-friendly:

• Resists chips, scratches, and cracks.

• Handles high heat (you can place hot pans on it).

• Lasts 20+ years with minimal care.

Marble is beautiful—but sensitive:

• It can be scratched with knives.

• Gets etched from acidic foods (like lemon).

• Needs sealing more often.

Which Stone Is Easier to Clean and Maintain?

Granite is lower maintenance.

Granite:

• Sealing once a year is usually enough.

• Wipe with soap and water.

• Resists most kitchen stains.

Marble:

• More porous. Needs sealing every 6 months.

• Easily stained by oil, wine, or juice.

• Needs gentle cleaning—no harsh chemicals.

Quick Care Tips:

• Always use cutting boards.

• Wipe spills right away—especially on marble.

• Use trivets for hot pots on either surface.

Which One Costs More?

It depends on the grade, finish, and design.

• Granite countertops in Winnipeg usually range between $65–$120 per sq. ft. installed.

• Marble countertops in Winnipeg can range from $90–$200 per sq. ft., especially for rare types like Calacatta or Statuario.

Why marble costs more long-term:

• Higher maintenance cost.

• More sealing and care.

• Easier to damage—can lead to repairs or early replacement.

Which One Looks Better?

Marble wins in pure visual beauty.

Why people love marble:

• Each slab is one-of-a-kind.

• Iconic veining and smooth texture.

• Popular in luxury kitchens.

Why granite is a solid choice:

• Comes in more earthy tones.

• Offers a bold, natural look.

• Great for rustic or traditional kitchens.

Design Tip: If you want a marble look but granite performance, consider honed or leathered granite finishes.

Bonus: Want to see how quartz compares in style? This quartz vs marble article has a great visual breakdown.

How Do Granite and Marble Handle Winnipeg’s Climate?

Granite is more stable in cold and dry air.

Winnipeg winters are tough on natural materials. Granite handles temperature swings and dryness better than marble.

Granite:

• Won’t crack due to cold

• Doesn’t shift much with humidity changes.

Marble:

• Softer stone—more sensitive to moisture and thermal expansion.

• Needs more care in homes with fluctuating indoor humidity.

Step-by-Step Guide: How to Choose Between Granite and Marble

Step 1: Think about your kitchen use. → Heavy use? Go for granite. Light cooking? Marble could work.

Step 2: Be honest about cleaning. → Not into regular sealing? Granite's your friend.

Step 3: Set your budget. → Granite costs less and lasts longer.

Step 4: Visit a local showroom. → Touch, feel, and compare slabs in real light.

Step 5: Ask your installer. → A local expert like Rockwood can help match the stone to use.

Why Winnipeg Homeowners Choose Rockwood Stone Countertops

At Rockwood Stone Countertops, we help you choose the right stone—based on how you live.

If you're leaning toward marble countertops in Winnipeg, we offer hand-picked slabs, expert advice, and flawless installation. You don’t just get stone—you get the right guidance and long-term support.

Summary: Go for Granite or Stick with Marble?

Feature	Granite	Marble
Durability	✔️ High	❌ Lower
Maintenance	✔️ Low	❌ High
Heat Resistance	✔️ Very good	✔️ Good
Appearance	✔️ Bold, varied	✔️ Elegant, luxurious
Cost	✔️ More affordable	❌ More expensive
Climate Suitability	✔️ Stable in Winnipeg	❌ Needs more care

Final Thoughts

• Go with granite if you want something strong, worry-free, and budget-friendly.

• Stick with marble if you value beauty over durability and are ready to care for it.

No wrong choice here—just the right stone for your kitchen life.